Skip to main content

Meet Our Team

Get to know the team that’s here to help with your insurance needs.

Leadership
Alysia Brooks

Alysia Brooks
Partner, Agent

740-593-5573

PLCS, CLCS
Read More
Brenda James

Brenda James
Partner, Agent

740-962-9900

Read More
Russell Norris

Russell Norris
Partner, Agent

740-593-5573

Read More

Locate a team member by location.

Athens, OHMcConnelsville, OH
Athens, OH
Mallory Swaim

Mallory Swaim
Sales Agent

740-593-5573

Read More

Chase Reed
Sales Agent

740-593-5573

Chase Reed joined Mathews Insurance as a new business producer in early 2025. He specializes in helping individuals find tailored insurance solutions, bringing a creative and client-focused approach to every interaction.
A 2018 graduate of Federal Hocking High School, Chase remains actively involved in his community. He has coached baseball at various levels, from varsity to junior high, where he currently leads the school’s 7th grade team. He also serves as a youth baseball and softball umpire for a local league, reflecting his dedication to mentorship and teamwork.
Outside of work, Chase enjoys spending time with his family, especially his six younger siblings, and making regular trips to Cincinnati with his girlfriend, Arizzona, as a proud Bengals season ticket holder. Who Dey! Whether he’s helping clients, coaching young athletes, or calling plays behind the plate, Chase brings energy, dedication, and heart to everything he does — and looks forward to helping you with all your insurance needs.
Read More

Sharon Hickel
Customer Service Representative, Agent, Commercial Lines

740-593-5573

Read More

Karla Cale
Customer Service Representative, Agent

740-593-5573

Read More

Lori Coon
Customer Service Representative, Agent

740-593-5573

Read More
McConnelsville, OH

Jill Oliver
Customer Service Representative, Agent, Claims

740-962-9900

Read More

Prefer to speak with someone from Mathews Insurance?
Contact us directly.

Contact Us