Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team

Meet Our Team

Get to know the team that’s here to help with your insurance needs.

Leadership

Alysia Brooks
Partner, Agent
740-593-5573

PLCS, CLCS

Brenda James
Partner, Agent
740-962-9900

Russell Norris
Partner, Agent
740-593-5573

Locate a team member by location.

Athens, OH McConnelsville, OH

Athens, OH

Mallory Swaim
Sales Agent
740-593-5573

Brooke Ehrhardt
Customer Service Representative, Agent
740-593-5573

Gloria Jolley
Customer Service Representative, Agent, Claims
740-593-5573

Karla Cale
Customer Service Representative, Agent
740-593-5573

Lori Coon
Customer Service Representative, Agent
740-593-5573

Sharon Hickel
Customer Service Representative, Agent, Commercial Lines
740-593-5573

McConnelsville, OH

Jill Oliver
Customer Service Representative, Agent, Claims
740-962-9900

Prefer to speak with someone from Mathews Insurance?
Contact us directly.

Insurance Solutions

About Mathews Insurance

Get Help

Athens, OH Office

McConnelsville, OH Office

740-593-5573
Email Us
740-594-4782 fax

Visit Us

Experience the Value of an Independent Agency

At Mathews Insurance, we remain committed to the philosophy we were founded on over 75 years ago: when it comes to your insurance, you need a friendly, local insurance agent.

We are licensed in Ohio.