Skip to main content

Exceeding your insurance expectations. Keeping it local.

About Our Agency - Woman Looking Back While Using a Laptop in an Office With Her Colleagues

Home » About Our Agency

Find what you need for your insurance in your hometown.


Ohio Offices


Insurance Partners


Years in Business

We are your local agency serving Southeast Ohio.

When you hear the term “local insurance agency” we know what you’re thinking—an old-fashioned experience with limited technologies. But here at Mathews Insurance, that couldn’t be further from the truth. Sure, we’ve been around for over 75 years, but we’ve adapted to modern times and offer flexibility when it comes to your needs. And we know what you’re looking for—fast quotes, seamless policy management, and options that won’t break the bank. You can trust we have all that and more, while still delivering a personal experience, locally.

Let us do the shopping for you.

Sure, you can go online and shop for insurance yourself. In fact, you may be able to shop through a variety of quotes online in just seconds. But, can you be sure that you’re choosing a policy with the coverage you need based on your lifestyle and risks? That’s why it’s always better to work with a team that has that knowledge to back you up, and gets to know you. At Mathews Insurance, we partner with a variety of insurance companies, offering you the flexibility to find value in your insurance plan that fits your coverage and budget needs. So whichever way you are most comfortable reaching out, we encourage you to go for it! We look forward to hearing from you.

The Independent Agency Advantage

Here’s what makes our insurance agency different.

Personalized Solutions

Get the power of choice with insurance that’s designed for your unique needs.

Knowledgeable Service

We’ll be there for you with reliable service and support to help you make informed decisions.

Trusted Relationships

You can rely on us to simplify the insurance process and advise you on your insurance.

No hold buttons. No robots.

We’re just a team of caring humans ready to help.

Meet Our Team

Find Your Coverage

We’re here to help you explore your coverage options.

Request Quote

Read Mathews Insurance‘s Reviews

Read Our Reviews

Contact Mathews Insurance

Athens, OH

240 Columbus Road
Athens, OH 45701

McConnelsville, OH

120 E. Main Street
McConnelsville, OH 43756

Email Us
 740-594-4782 fax

Our Partnership

Our Mission

At Mathews Insurance, we remain committed to the philosophy we were founded on over 75 years ago: when it comes to your insurance, you need a friendly, local insurance agent.

Insurance Designed for Your Needs

Mathews Insurance is located in Athens, OH, and McConnelsville, OH, and licensed in Ohio.

Let’s Get Started

  1. Step 1Fill out the form.
  2. Step 2Review your options with us.
  3. Step 3Get the coverage you need.

Request an Insurance Quote

"*" indicates required fields

Date of Birth
If you do not have one, please input 'N/A'.
Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Don’t like forms? Contact us at 740-593-5573 or email us.