Skip to main content

Trusted by Tradition, Powered by Innovation

Protecting our community for decades, one policy at a time with Mathews Insurance.

Contact UsRequest a Quote

2

Ohio Offices

11

Insurance Partners

75

Years in Business

How can we help?

Learn About Us

Learn About Mathews Insurance

At Mathews Insurance, we’ve been protecting our clients for over 74 years. Back in the day, insurance was a different ball game. People craved face-to-face interaction and the peace of mind that came with it. Today, that’s now exactly the case. We understand that these days, time is of the essence, which is why we’ve adapted to modern times and technologies, while still upholding our founding philosophy of being your trusted local agency.

We may not have any quirky mascots, but we have something even better: a team of experienced agents who are dedicated to finding you highly competitive coverage options to fit your needs. Get a quote easily, let us do the shopping around for you, and even manage your policy online in just a few clicks. Plus, you can always count on us to be responsive and available whenever you need us, whether that’s by phone, email, text, or social media. So, if you’re on the hunt for better insurance, give us a call and experience the difference that comes with working with a local agency that truly cares about your peace of mind.

Mathews Insurance - Logo Icon

At Mathews Insurance, we still stand behind the philosophy that we were founded on. When it comes to your insurance agency, it should be friendly, reliable and local.

Our Athens, OH Google ReviewsOur McConnelsville, OH Google Reviews

Get to Know Your Neighborhood Team

Mathews Insurance has locations in Athens, OH, and McConnelsville, OH. Read more about our team and get in touch today!

Meet Our Team

Whether It’s Personal or Business, We Have Solutions

Learn more about the personal insurance and business insurance products we offer at Mathews Insurance.

Request a Quote

Our Clients Rave About Us

The Independent Agency Advantage

What makes our independent insurance agency different?

We offer a wide variety of insurance solutions.

We are there for you in your time of need.

We are by your side every step of the way.

We are licensed insurance advisors.

Partner-OIA

Get More Options!

We proudly represent Aegis, Foremost, Progressive, and more!

Interactive Graphic

Click it. Read it. Cover it.

  1. Click on the hotspots.
  2. Discover your risks.
  3. Explore coverage options.

Not what you’re looking for?

Explore more interactive graphics.

Mathews Insurance - Logo Icon White

Manage Your Policies

Already a client of Mathews Insurance? Visit our Service Center to make requests and manage your insurance.

Visit Service Center

Let’s Get Started

  1. Step 1Fill out the form.
  2. Step 2Review your options with us.
  3. Step 3Get the coverage you need.

Contact Mathews Insurance

"*" indicates required fields

Name
Date of Birth
Address
If you do not have one, please input 'N/A'.
Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Don’t like forms? Contact us at 740-593-5573 or email us.